The New York Yankees have just made headlines after designating veteran infielder DJ LeMahieu for assignment. The move comes as a shock to many fans, as LeMahieu has been a key figure in the Yankees’ infield since 2019. LeMahieu is still owed around $22 million through 2026, making his now vacant roster spot fairly expensive. The move appears tied to a larger infield reshuffle, as Jazz Chisholm Jr. returns to his natural position at second base, and Oswald Peraza takes over at third. Manager Aaron Boone recently confirmed that LeMahieu would no longer see time at third, foreshadowing his removal from the active roster.
Performance Dip and Age Catching Up
LeMahieu’s struggles this season have been apparent. He is slashing just .266/.323/.351 with a .674 OPS in limited playing time. His production has dropped off since his peak years, and a string of leg and foot injuries has limited his mobility and consistency at the plate. The veteran missed much of spring training with a calf strain and has not fully bounced back. Boone’s recent comments made it clear that the Yankees no longer view him as an everyday option. His diminished range and declining bat speed make him a liability in a competitive division. For a team trying to claw its way back up the standings, carrying a fading bench bat with a hefty contract no longer made sense.
Get Your Inside The Diamonds Merchandise Here
Youth and Athleticism Reshaping the Infield
The Yankees’ infield dynamic shifted dramatically with Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s return from injury. Chisholm’s speed and defensive instincts give the team a much-needed spark in the middle infield. That shift moved Oswald Peraza into the starting role at third base, pushing LeMahieu further down the depth chart. The organization has also been encouraged by Jorbit Vivas’ development, recalling him to the major league roster as the corresponding move. Simply put, there was no longer a clear role for LeMahieu. With the trade deadline approaching, the Yankees are eager to create flexibility on the roster. Removing LeMahieu opens a path to add a more impactful contributor or make room for an incoming trade piece.
Trade Deadline Pressure Forces Hard Choices
New York’s recent slide has amplified calls for change. After starting the year strong, the Yankees have stumbled to a 7–16 stretch, falling to second place in the AL East for the first time since April. General manager Brian Cashman is under pressure to act ahead of the July 31 deadline. Third base has emerged as a position of need, and the Yankees are rumored to be eyeing players like Ryan McMahon or Ke’Bryan Hayes. LeMahieu’s presence blocked any real upgrade. By cutting ties now, the Yankees gain flexibility to reshape the infield and make an aggressive move in the coming weeks. The timing of the DFA shows that the front office is ready to pivot toward a win-now strategy, even if it means parting with a clubhouse favorite.
Purchase Tickets via Ticketmaster
A Legacy Worth Remembering
Though his recent performance has been uneven, LeMahieu’s contributions to the Yankees cannot be overstated. In 2019, he delivered a breakout season, hitting .327 with 26 home runs and 102 RBIs. He followed that with a batting title in 2020, posting a league-best .364 average during the shortened season. LeMahieu became the first player in the modern era to win a batting title in both leagues, having done so in Colorado in 2016. He was a two-time All-Star in New York and won a Silver Slugger Award during his peak. His bat-to-ball skills, situational awareness, and quiet leadership made him a fan favorite and an asset in the lineup.
Defensive Versatility and Gold Glove Talent
LeMahieu’s glove was another pillar of his value to the team. He played first, second, and third base at a high level, winning multiple Gold Gloves across his career. His ability to slot into any infield position gave the Yankees critical flexibility during injury-riddled stretches. From 2019 through 2021, his defense was among the most consistent in the American League. Even as his offensive numbers declined, he continued to field his position cleanly. Unfortunately, nagging foot and toe injuries caught up with him. His once-smooth footwork and strong lateral movement have declined, especially in the last two seasons.
Respect in the Clubhouse and Around the League
Inside the Yankees’ clubhouse, LeMahieu was widely respected. His work ethic and calm demeanor earned him the nickname “LeMachine.” Coaches and teammates valued his professionalism, and he set an example for younger players. Even as his playing time diminished, he stayed ready and contributed in small moments. He battled through injuries with little complaint and adapted to new roles without making waves. That kind of leadership matters, especially in a clubhouse that has seen constant roster churn over the last two seasons. His departure leaves a void that statistics alone won’t fill.
What’s Next for LeMahieu?
Designating LeMahieu for assignment doesn’t mean his career is over, but it does raise questions about what comes next. At age 36, with declining speed and production, he’s unlikely to attract significant interest around the league. If no suitors emerge, LeMahieu could choose to retire, bringing an accomplished career to a quiet close. Either way, his time in pinstripes is over.
End of an Era, Beginning of a New Phase
The Yankees’ decision to DFA DJ LeMahieu marks the end of an important era. From his breakout in 2019 through his recent struggles, he remained a steady, respected presence. But the team’s needs have changed. With youth pushing up from the farm system and the trade deadline looming, there’s little room for sentimentality. The Yankees are focused on getting younger, faster, and more aggressive. LeMahieu’s exit may sting now, but the move underscores their urgency to compete in a crowded playoff race. His legacy will remain part of the Yankees’ modern narrative, even as the team turns the page.
