Breaking: Gerrit Cole to Undergo Tommy John

In a devastating blow to the New York Yankees, ace Gerrit Cole will have Tommy John surgery. Gerrit Cole will miss the entire 2025 season and most likely part of 2026. The decision follows evaluations of his right elbow after a concerning spring training outing. During that outing, Gerrit Cole allowed six runs over 2 2/3 innings.

Purchase tickets via Ticketmaster

Cole, a former AL Cy Young winner, has battled elbow issues before. Last season, Gerrit Cole was sidelined until June due to inflammation and edema in the same elbow. He made only 17 starts last season for the Yankees. His next start for the Yankees will hopefully be sometime in 2026. Now, after further imaging and consultations, Gerrit Cole needs surgery as advised.

Aftermath

The timing couldn’t be worse for New York. Fellow starter Luis Gil is facing a high-grade lat strain. He will be out for at least three months. This situation forces the Yankees to explore internal options. One potential replacement is right-hander Will Warren, who has impressed this spring with a 1.54 ERA over 11 2/3 innings. With the current injuries, befriending Gerrit Cole off the field might provide the Yankees some moral support. While this injury certainly, will hurt the Yankees, the rest of the AL East is now wide open this season.

Manager Aaron Boone acknowledged the tough situation. He said, “Unfortunately, sometimes it’s part of the game… We’ll support our guy and get him right.” The Yankees must pivot quickly. They need to decide whether to rely on in-house talent or seek outside help before Opening Day.

Get Your Inside The Diamonds Merchandise Here

Cole’s surgery highlights the growing concerns over pitcher injuries in MLB. With the increasing frequency of Tommy John procedures, teams continue to refine workload management and injury prevention strategies.

For now, the Yankees fans will have to wait. They need to see what the next move is for the front office to address this glaring need. They need to act fast as the opening series against the Milwaukee Brewers is right around the corner. Gerrit Cole being absence will be deeply felt by the team.