The 2025 season has taken an unexpected turn for the Yankees’ young shortstop. Anthony Volpe’s defensive struggles have become a recurring theme in headlines and fan discussions. Though once lauded for his Gold‑Glove‑caliber range, Volpe now leads the American League in errors and has drawn criticism for a series of high‑profile misplays, prompting a shortstop identity crisis in New York.
Numbers Don’t Lie
From a statistical lens, Volpe’s defensive decline is stark. Entering July 22, he has 12 errors in 99 games, the most in the American League at his position. His fielding percentage has also dropped to .964, down from .972 last season. Despite still logging a high range factor (3.44), his lapses, especially poor throwing decisions, have turned routine plays into costly mistakes. Advanced stats reflect the trend, showing a negative shift in defensive runs saved and dWAR compared with his 2023 peak. Scouts note a drop in arm accuracy and momentum on throws, raising questions about his footwork and foot‑to‑hand coordination. When a shortstop’s fundamentals slip, the ripple effects are immediate: extra baserunners, extended innings, and rising tension in a pressure‑packed market like New York.
The Roots of Anthony Volpe’s Defensive Struggles
Understanding why these issues surfaced now requires context. Volpe suffered a left shoulder injury on May 3 and took a pitch to the elbow on June 6th. While he played through both instances, the ailments may have subtly altered his throwing mechanics. He admitted in postgame interviews to being “frustrated” about the errors, pointing to momentary breaks in concentration. Furthermore, increased pressure has intensified scrutiny. Aaron Boone has repeatedly defended Volpe, writing off the errors as a few extra plays and insisting he remains an elite shortstop. But fans and analysts argue Boone’s support may be shielding deeper issues. Even Alex Rodriguez has chimed in about whether Volpe’s glove can anchor a championship defense. Critics label the narrative a product of brainwashed cheerleading, noting that his errors far outpace the league average for shortstops.
Get Your Inside The Diamonds Merchandise Here
On‑Field Repercussions to Volpe’s Defensive Struggles
Volpe’s misplays are having tangible effects. In a recent series against the Cubs, he mishandled a routine grounder and made a “casual” throw that failed to end the inning, an error that directly led to a run. These lapses coincide with a .214 batting average and .671 OPS, compounding concerns. The Yankees front office has taken note. GM Brian Cashman reaffirmed that Volpe remains “our shortstop,” citing his contributions in the 2024 playoffs and attributing his slump to shoulder and elbow issues. Yet he also admitted that the defense “hasn’t played out this year as much,” acknowledging that Volpe is playing through physical setbacks. With the July 31 trade deadline approaching, the Yankees appear unlikely to seek a shortstop replacement. Instead, they’re focusing on bullpen and bench upgrades, signaling confidence that Volpe can recover in place.
Can Coaching and Reps Rescue His Defense?
The path forward may lie in incremental fixes. Volpe has spoken about working closely with infield coaches to restore proper footwork and throw rhythm. Managers suggest more repetition will help, yet in-season adjustments carry risk. Live-game errors persist, and off-days offer limited opportunity for a mechanics overhaul.
An alternative is a short‑term demotion. The Mets recently sent Francisco Alvarez to Triple‑A during a similar slump, and the Yankees reportedly considered sending Volpe down to recalibrate. However, both Boone and Cashman have resisted that route so far, citing his value and past track record. The additional complication comes from the Yankees’ lack of depth at the position. Oswald Peraza is a competent defender but lacks production at the plate. The same can be said of Orbit Vivas. The only minor league option the team could consider is George Lombard Jr., but he is presently experiencing his own set of growing pains in AA Somerset.
Is This a Fluke or a Trend?
Looking ahead, the question looms: Are these issues temporary hiccups or the start of a troubling trend? There’s reason for cautious optimism. Volpe’s underlying metrics, like hard‑hit rate and wOBA, are in line with expectations, and his defensive range remains elite.
Still, fielding is as much mental as physical. Confidence fractured can lead to hesitation, and hesitation equals mistakes, especially in crunch time. If Volpe can restore a measure of consistency, both the club and the fans could look back on this period as a passing challenge. But if errors continue at this pace, the Yankees are right back where they started; instability on the left side of the infield.
Purchase Tickets via Ticketmaster
The Stakes
The impact of Volpe’s ongoing defensive woes extends beyond stat lines. In a tight AL East race, every run and every play matters, and errors that lead to free bases and longer innings can tip tight ballgames. Additionally, fans are losing patience. The Yankee faithful expect the team to be perennial World Series contenders, and the margins for error are razor-thin.
A Defensive Identity in Flux
Anthony Volpe’s defensive struggles have become the central hurdle in his 2025 narrative. Plagued by the usual bumps and bruises of a 162-game season, mechanical breakdowns, and mounting public criticism, the polished shortstop of 2023 now wrestles with inconsistency. The organization’s backing is strong, yet tangible improvements are urgently needed.
The next month will be pivotal. Volpe has to make necessary adjustments or the Yankees may be forced to consider more drastic long-term solutions. Either way, finding resolution is essential for his growth and the team’s postseason aspirations.
