The Yankees are approaching the end of July with more questions than answers. Injuries have gutted their rotation, the bullpen has grown shaky, and production at third base remains inconsistent. As the front office surveys the market, the central issue is defining the Yankees’ trade deadline priorities. This isn’t a team that needs a full teardown or splashy overcorrection. The core of the team remains solid, but targeted reinforcements are needed if the Yankees hope to play in October. The right moves could elevate the season’s trajectory.
Yankees Trade Deadline Priorities Begin with the Rotation
The rotation is patchwork at best. Luis Gil’s return might help, but banking on health to solve a depth problem is wishful thinking. At present, the Yankees have nine pitchers on the injured list, and the backend starters have struggled to consistently eat innings.
That puts someone like Mitch Keller in sharp focus. The Pirates starter has quietly logged a 3.48 ERA across 20 starts and brings the kind of mid-rotation reliability that doesn’t require selling the farm. Crucially, he’s not a rental, with controllable years through 2028.
If the Yankees want to be serious contenders, acquiring a durable arm needs to top the list of Yankees trade deadline priorities. Whether that’s Keller or a higher-end option like Sandy Alcantara will depend on what they’re willing to give up and how desperate they feel.
Purchase Tickets via Ticketmaster
Bullpen Reinforcements Should Rank High Among Yankees Trade Deadline Priorities
The bullpen situation is trending toward unsustainable. Jonathan Loáisiga has been a shell of himself, and Luke Weaver’s usage rate feels more like a stopgap than a plan. Without late-inning stability, the pressure on the offense and the starter du jour compounds quickly.
Veterans like David Robertson might not electrify the fanbase, but he could offer a stabilizing presence. Alternatively, they could take a bigger swing at someone like Ryan Helsley, though that comes with a higher cost and risk profile.
Among Yankees trade deadline priorities, a bullpen arm won’t draw many headlines, but it might make the difference in the second half of the season.
Upgrading Third Base Shouldn’t Be Overlooked
Stability at the hot corner has been a problem for at least the last three seasons. With DJ LeMahieu now gone, internal depth is non-existent. The Yankees don’t need to make a splash here. A league-average bat and competent defense would be a massive upgrade over the platoon of Jorbit Vivas and Oswald Peraza.
Eugenio Suárez fits that mold. He’s in the top three in the league in RBIs as well as 31 home runs. This is Suárez’s contract year, so that makes him a rental, but one that offers high impact and low commitment. The question then becomes, what will Brian Cashman part with to land Suárez? His recent statements suggest that no prospect is untouchable, but parting with Schlittler or Jones seems unlikely, even for Eugenio Suárez.
Get Your Inside The Diamonds Merchandise Here
Balancing Internal Depth with External Moves
Cam Schlittler has flashed potential, and Luis Gil’s return timeline puts him in the mix by early August. Aaron Boone has stressed the need for internal consistency and competition, but waiting on internal solutions while treading water in a tight division race is a high-risk game.
A smart front office doesn’t just chase stars; it addresses pain points with urgency. The deadline isn’t just about patching. The Yankees don’t need to blow it up. They need to move quickly, surgically, and with a clear sense of where this team can go if healthy and reinforced.
Crucial Junction
The Yankees’ trade deadline priorities aren’t complicated or unattainable, but they are critical. A mid-rotation starter, a dependable bullpen arm, and a third baseman with consistency would change this team’s posture overnight. Cashman doesn’t need to make moves for the flashiest players; he needs to make moves for the right players. If the Yankees intend to remain in the hunt for 28, they cannot stand still while the competition gets better. The deadline won’t wait. And neither will the rest of the division.
