To paraphrase the late Yogi Berra, it’s getting late early. The Yankees have looked completely out matched since at least the middle of June, and they are running out of time to do something about it. The club is 5.5 games out of first place and 2.5 games behind the second place Red Sox. They are currently tied with the Mariners for a Wild Card spot and for Yankee fans, that isn’t good enough.
Yankees Midseason Slide Accelerates
On June 10, Max Fried dialed in seven solid innings against Kansas City, and the offense erupted for a 10‑2 win, lifting their record to 40‑25. That seemed like a reset after a rough series against Boston, but the reset didn’t stick. In the weeks that followed, the Yankees have totally collapsed. Since June 13, they’ve gone 18‑29, one of baseball’s worst stretches. That slump has erased early gains and exposed vulnerabilities.
Get Your Inside The Diamonds Merchandise Here
Pitching and Defense Weaknesses
Failure is obvious all over the diamond and on both sides of the ball. They have the 8th most errors in the league, most of which coming from shortstop Anthony Volpe and 2nd baseman Jazz Chisholm. The fifth worst fielding percentage, and a team ERA that was once in the top five in baseball, now sitting at 17th. Devin Williams has shown to be an unreliable closer, blowing his third save of the season last night in Arlington. The rest of the bullpen doesn’t seem much better, even after the trade deadline.
Pitching Depth Shakes Under Deadline Moves
The Yankees released veteran Marcus Stroman on August 1, aiming to refresh the pitching staff. They added David Bednar, Camilo Doval, and Jake Bird at the deadline, and Luis Gil returned to the rotation after starting the season on the IL. Despite all these moves, the roster has yet to see noticable improvement. In the first game after these additions, the Yankees’ bullpen managed to blow a six-run lead that would lead to a 13-12 loss in Miami.
Offense Loses Its Edge When It Matters
It seems like there is a rule that prevents the team from completing a game with strong offense, good pitching, and fundamentally sound defense. If the pitching is good, the team can’t produce runs. If the offense is on fire, the pitching gives up an equal amount of runs. If both of these are clicking, the defense falls apart. From watching the team, a person could be forgiven for thinking they were losing on purpose. Obviously, they aren’t but it isn’t immediately obvious that they are playing to win at the very least. The Yankees midseason slide is turning into a full disaster.
Purchase Tickets via Ticketmaster
Leadership in the Hot Seat
Pressure has shifted upward. Former Yankee legends Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez have very openly expressed their frustration with this brand of Yankees baseball. While Manager Aaron Boone may hold players accountable in the clubhouse, it is clearly not having the desired effect. The team continues to underperform, which is especially egregious considering there are four former MVPs in the lineup.
Roster Construction Faces Tough Questions
You can patch a bullpen and swap arms, but when defense fails and fundamentals unravel, those quick fixes don’t hold. Fans and analysts alike have captured the worry: poor defense, mispositioned players, and weak construction. In other words, the team isn’t built to win. The Yankees sit at 60‑53, seven games above .500. They still have a slim playoff chance, but only if they fix things fast. That means tightening up at every level: rotation, bullpen, defense, leadership.
